Mystery and Puzzle Games subscription boxes
10 still shipping, 7 closed or paused. Ranked by our rating.
SHIP TOUS 
Finders Seekers Monthly mail-order mystery games set in a new country each time, for groups or solo ★★★★☆ 4.2Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS 
Society of Curiosities Mail-order mystery games that mix physical artifacts with websites, texts and real research ★★★★☆ 4.2Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS 
Dear Holmes Sherlock Holmes mysteries delivered as weekly clue letters through the mail ★★★★☆ 4.1Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOCA 
The Mysterious Package Company Atmospheric mystery and puzzle experiences told through physical artifacts by mail ★★★★☆ 4.1Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS 
The Deadbolt Mystery Society Monthly standalone murder mystery boxes with physical clues and online interactive parts ★★★★☆ 4.0Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOGB 
Cosykiller Hand-packed historical murder-mystery case files to solve at home, from Red Herring Games ★★★★☆ 3.9Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS 
The Curiosity Box Quarterly science toys, puzzles and curios for adults from Vsauce's Michael Stevens ★★★★☆ 3.9Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS 
Hunt A Killer Physical murder mystery cases full of realistic evidence you solve at home ★★★★☆ 3.8Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS 
The Conundrum Box Story-driven escape room boxes with themed music and extras, monthly or bimonthly ★★★★☆ 3.8Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOAU 
Puzzle Post UK-designed escape room and cold case games sold as standalone kits for group play ★★★★☆ 3.5Mystery and Puzzle Games
Finders Seekers Monthly mail-order mystery games set in a new country each time, for groups or solo ★★★★☆ 4.2Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS Society of Curiosities Mail-order mystery games that mix physical artifacts with websites, texts and real research ★★★★☆ 4.2Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS Dear Holmes Sherlock Holmes mysteries delivered as weekly clue letters through the mail ★★★★☆ 4.1Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOCA The Mysterious Package Company Atmospheric mystery and puzzle experiences told through physical artifacts by mail ★★★★☆ 4.1Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS The Deadbolt Mystery Society Monthly standalone murder mystery boxes with physical clues and online interactive parts ★★★★☆ 4.0Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOGB Cosykiller Hand-packed historical murder-mystery case files to solve at home, from Red Herring Games ★★★★☆ 3.9Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS The Curiosity Box Quarterly science toys, puzzles and curios for adults from Vsauce's Michael Stevens ★★★★☆ 3.9Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS Hunt A Killer Physical murder mystery cases full of realistic evidence you solve at home ★★★★☆ 3.8Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS The Conundrum Box Story-driven escape room boxes with themed music and extras, monthly or bimonthly ★★★★☆ 3.8Mystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOAU Puzzle Post UK-designed escape room and cold case games sold as standalone kits for group play ★★★★☆ 3.5Mystery and Puzzle Games ×No longer shipping
SHIP TOCA 
Moved Curious Correspondence Former mail-based escape room series, now just a product line on another store MovedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS 
Closed Dispatch by Breakout Games Breakout's monthly mail mystery subscription, now discontinued ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS site offline Closed Escape the Crate Closed mail order escape room subscription; the old domain now hosts a dog care business ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS 
Closed Murder & Co Closed monthly crime solving game mixing story, puzzles, codes and gift items as clues ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS site offline Closed PostCurious (The Tale of Ord) Closed 2018 mail puzzle story told over four months, now out of print ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOGB site offline Closed The Detective Society Closed UK murder mystery subscription that posted paper case files to solve at home ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS 
Closed The Mystery Experiences Company Closed US mystery and puzzle game subscription formerly sold on Cratejoy ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games
Moved Curious Correspondence Former mail-based escape room series, now just a product line on another store MovedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS Closed Dispatch by Breakout Games Breakout's monthly mail mystery subscription, now discontinued ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS site offline Closed Escape the Crate Closed mail order escape room subscription; the old domain now hosts a dog care business ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS Closed Murder & Co Closed monthly crime solving game mixing story, puzzles, codes and gift items as clues ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS site offline Closed PostCurious (The Tale of Ord) Closed 2018 mail puzzle story told over four months, now out of print ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOGB site offline Closed The Detective Society Closed UK murder mystery subscription that posted paper case files to solve at home ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games SHIP TOUS Closed The Mystery Experiences Company Closed US mystery and puzzle game subscription formerly sold on Cratejoy ClosedMystery and Puzzle Games